Summary of Customer Ratings & Reviews
Skin Tone:: Medium
Great formula but not with the price
I cannot keep an eyeliner on my waterline and this eyeliner was impressive in that regard - relatively smudge proof. However, I found it tugged and pieces of it broke off when i was applying. Because of that, and perhaps because there isn't much product, it ran out in 2-3 weeks and for that reason I can't justify repurchasing.
its a miss from me
I've really tried all the black eyeliners there are out there and this one is not bad but there are definitely better ones out there around a similar price. I think the eyeliner is very overpriced for the cheap packaging, think products that will snap easily if you're not careful. BUT the actual eyeliner is long lasting...
Skin Tone:: Fair
Considering the price is mid-range, I didn't expect there to be so little eyeliner in the pen. Every. time I applied it, the eyeliner would snap off. It was difficult to get a good line or to adjust how much you put on as it kept breaking. It smudged easily and teh bendable sponge was really ineffective. A total waste of money.
Best Use: Lengthening
Skin Tone:: Medium
Recommends this product: Yes
I have this in black and it's a great eyeliner. It does wear well so well and I really like the dark pigment and as always the packaging is fabulous. I only have it 4 stars as I do think it smudges and sometimes I don't want to create a look like that. Other than that, a really good eye liner
Age: Under 30
Nice, creamy and blendable but i wanted this to tightline my upper water line and it's easy to do this but it does transfer to the bottom waterline, which is not what i want. I feel like it makes my eyes overly watery too. I used to love the old formula and that one never transferred, it would last all day. So definitely not transfer proof, would be good for smudging though